- Written by Alexander Green, Investment U Investment Director
- Friday, 20 April 2012
Ever wonder what happens when greed meets stupidity in the stock market? For a profound example, take a look at the recent free fall in Argentina’s largest oil and gas company, YPF (NYSE: YPF).
The country’s President Cristina Kirchner recently took a watershed step in expanding the state’s grip on the economy, saying she will send a bill to Congress to nationalize the firm.
Predictably, shares of YPF – and other Argentine stocks – gapped down on the news.
Kirchner declared that this historic move must be made because the petroleum industry is of “national public interest.” Of course, what industry isn’t? Banking? Telecommunications? Manufacturing? Agriculture?
Kirchner insists that YPF’s low production is forcing the country to spend heavily on imported energy at a time when it is experiencing a scarcity of dollars due to capital flight. And why is Argentina hemorrhaging capital? Because of boneheaded moves like this one.
YPF’s majority shareholder, Spanish energy group Repsol, is not taking this theft lying down. The Madrid government has threatened swift retaliation. And Spain’s Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy stated the obvious when he said the Spanish company’s controlling stake in YPF – which Repsol was planning to sell to China’s Sinopec – was being expropriated “without any justification.”
Given that most successful developing nations are privatizing industries rather than nationalizing them – and given that investment capital always flows where it is treated best (and conversely flees those countries where it is treated badly) – why would Kirchner do this?
One answer is stupidity. The other is hubris.
There is absolutely no reason to think that a bunch of politicians and bureaucrats – or their appointees – could run YPF better than Repsol, one of the world’s leading energy groups. (Just as there is no reason to think the U.S. government can do a better job than private equity groups of backing speculative solar companies like Solyndra.)
And if Argentina is willing to nationalize its leading oil company, which company (or companies) is next? Here’s a potential hit list, 17 Argentine companies that trade on the NYSE or Nasdaq. If you’re holding any of them, sell them immediately.
|Alto Palermo||APSA||Real Estate Inv&Serv|
|BBVA Banco Frances||BFR||Banks|
|Grupo Financiero Galicia||GGAL||Banks|
|IRSA Inversiones y Representaciones||IRS||Real Estate Inv&Serv|
|Nortel Invesora – Series B||NTL||Fixed Line Telecom.|
|Pampa Energia||PAM||Financial Services|
|Petrobras Energia||PZE||Oil & Gas Producers|
|Telecom Argentina||TEO||Fixed Line Telecom.|
|Telefonica de Argentina||TEF||Fixed Line Telecom.|
|Transportadora de Gas del Sur||TGS||OilEquip.,Serv.&Dist|
|YPF||YPF||Oil & Gas Producers|
The tragic part of this power grab – which has undeniable populist appeal in some quarters – is that it will only undermine investor confidence and do lasting damage to the Argentine currency, the Argentine economy and, ultimately, middle-class Argentinians.
This move is not just greedy. It’s profoundly dim. But then, Ronald Reagan said it best:
“The best minds cannot be found in government. If they could, the private sector would hire them away.”
Alexander Green at InvestmentU
Alexander Green is the Chief Investment Strategist of Investment U. A Wall Street veteran, he has more than 20 years of experience as a research analyst, investment advisor, financial writer and portfolio manager.
Mr. Green has been featured on The O’Reilly Factor, and has been profiled by The Wall Street Journal, BusinessWeek, Forbes, Kiplinger’s Personal Finance, C-SPAN and CNBC among others.
Mr. Green is also the author of three bestsellers “The Gone Fishin’ Portfolio: Get Wise, Get Wealthy… And Get On With Your Life, The Secret of Shelter Island: Money and What Matters” and “Beyond Wealth: The Road Map to a Rich Life.”
Disclaimer: Nothing in this commentary should be construed as investment advice or guidance or any recommendation to buy or sell any financial instrument. It is not intended as investment advice or guidance, nor is it offered as such. It is solely the opinion of the writer, who is NOT an investment counselor/professional. All content of this commentary is solely an expression of his personal interests and is posted as free-of-charge commentary and is subject to error and change without notice. Please do your own due diligence before investing in ANYTHING. The presence of a link to a website does not indicate approval or endorsement of that website or any services, products or opinions that may be offered by them.